Graphic Novels vs. Comic Books

Graphic Novels vs. Comic Books

As you can already tell, I read a lot of graphic novels. I do not, however, read comic books. When I show people the Graphic novel that I am reading, the normal reaction is “Why are you reading a comic book?” They are not the same thing at all. Graphic Novels have complex plots and characters as would a novel. Whereas a comic book is a periodical told over several issues spanning months or even years with action center plots. They are most definitely not the same thing. I will be discussing both in detail then providing you with some examples of the Graphic Novels in this blog entry!

Similarities between Graphic Novels and Comic Books

  • Use Illustrations to tell a story
  • Published
  • Panel style illustrations
  • Target audiences can be Children, YA, and Adults depending on the content

Difference between Graphic Novels and Comic Books:

Stories

Graphic Novels (GN)- Stories are longer and more complex; detailed plot, characters, backgrounds of characters, etc. (Reads like a book)

Comic Books (CB)- Stories are short (sometimes under 22 pages in length). Does not go into depth with characters but more action centered plots

Plot

GN- Story has a beginning, middle, and end- Typically wrapped up in one book

CB- Story is typically periodicals and told over several issues; to be continued to the next issue

Published

GN- Published like a book

CB- Published monthly or serialized

Printed

GN- Books are bound like a book (glued); printed on better paper and color is more vivid

CB- Typically bound with “Saddle Stitching” with staples; printed on cheaper paper with brighter than life colors

Genres

GN- Fiction or non-fiction

CB- Fiction (Superheroes, sci-fi, or cartoons)

Examples of Comic Books:

  • Superman
  • X-Men
  • Spiderman
  • Batman
  • Avengers
  • Comic Magazines (Mad Magazine, Action Comics, etc).
  • Manga is a form of both comics and graphic novels (In this case, I am putting it in the comics section).
  • Peanuts

Serialized Comic Books but with complex characters and plots (sometimes even published monthly- borders comic books):

  • “The Walking Dead” series by Robert Kirkman and Tony Moore
  • “Saga” series by Brian K. Vaughan and Fiona Staples
  • “The Watchmen” series by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons & John Higgins
  • “Y: The Last Man” series by Brian Vaughan and Pia Guerra

Examples of Graphic Novels (these are merely examples and not the best of GN):

Fiction:

  • “Blankets” by Craig Thompson
    • Coming of age novel
  • “Ghost World” by Daniel Clowes
  • “American Born Chinese” by Gene Luen Yang
  • “This One Summer” by Mariko Tamaki and Jillian Tamaki
    • Coming of age novel
  • “Waves” by Ingrid Chabbert and Carole Maurel
    • Deals with an abortion

Adaptions of Novels:

  • “To Kill a Mockingbird” by Harper Lee; Fred Fordham
  • “The Lightening Thief”  by Rick Riordan; Robert Venditti and Attila Futaki
  • “The Handmaid’s Tale” by Margaret Atwood; Renee Nault
  • “Jane” by Aline McKenna and Ramon K. Perez
    • Modern re-telling of “Jane Eyre”

Non-Fiction:

  • “The Twilight Man: Rod Serling and the Birth of Television” by Koren Shadmi
    • Biography
  • “Drowned City” by Don Brown
    • Hurricane Katrina before and after
  • “Thoreau at Walden” by John Porcellino
    • Biography
  • “They Called Us Enemy” by George Takei, Justin Eisinger, and Steven Scott
    • Internment Camps WWII
  • “March” by Andrew Aydin and John Lewis
    • Civil Rights

Historical Fiction:

  • “Maus” by Art Spiegelman
    • WWII
  • “Persepolis” by Marjane Satrapi
    • Growing up in Iran
  • “White Bird” by R.J. Palacio
    • WWII
  • “My Friend, Dahmer” by Derf
    • Jeffery Dahmer in his teenage years

Reviewing Graphic Novels:

When I review a graphic novel, it is like a normal book review. The only difference is that I often mention the graphics. Sometimes the graphics and/or the placement of the panels play an important part of my review. I typically place the review on all platforms that I generally place any other novel.

Counting Towards Your Reading Goals:

Yes, I count every Graphic Novel towards my reading goals. I typically read each Graphic Novel as I would a regular novel. Sometimes Graphic Novels take me just as long to read. I like to admire the illustrations but also read the story as I would a typical novel. I knew there will always be people that will never consider this form to be a novel, but I will always count it towards mine!

Drop a comment with your favorite Graphic Novel or Comic Book on this post! Happy Reading, everyone! Thanks for stopping by and reading!

Be the first to comment on "Graphic Novels vs. Comic Books"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*